Home > Preservation News >

New Haven: Once-Threatened House Restored

Once threatened with demolition, a house in the city’s Westville section has been restored. The Miles and Eleazer Hotchkiss house, built in about 1835 by two brothers who owned a nearby paper mill, had been vacant for more than 25 years and fallen into disrepair. A developer wanted to demolish the Greek Revival house to build condominiums, a plan that sparked widespread community opposition.

Westville Village Renaissance Alliance (WVRA), a Connecticut Main Street organization, led the opposition. The group wanted to encourage preservation not only in the main business corridor and the high-income residential areas of Westville, but also in the less prosperous area where the Hotchkiss house is located, a designated empowerment zone.

The developer finally sold the house to two local activists, Thea Buxbaum and Rebecca Gratz, to hold for WVRA. The plan was for WVRA to apply for grant funds to restore the house and operate it as a site for community events and to produce income for the organization.

WVRA nominated the house to the State Register and obtained an Historic Preservation Technical Assistance Grant from the Connecticut Trust to prepare renovation plans, and Buxbaum and Gratz restored the house themselves, working with Kenneth Boroson Architects and contractor JNA Construction, both of New Haven.

            Due to the economic downturn, the house’s long-term use remains uncertain. Possibilities include a bed-and-breakfast, studios for local artists, or multi-family housing. Buxbaum hopes that WVRA eventually will be able to take over the building.